Gears manufactured by Forest City Gear are found in aerospace, medical, military and other industrial applications, many of which require high process capability where honing provides critical advantages in control and consistency.
Honing plays a pivotal role in providing the high quality and performance of Forest City Gear's products. By employing two Sunnen SV Series honing systems, as well as an SH-4000 tube hone, the shop achieves its objectives.
Forest City Gear needed to have more control of its bore tolerances. Sunnen hones allowed it to meet the roundness and perpendicularity requirements for finished parts, as well as the in-process requirements for gear finishing.
Forest City Gear's principal products are fine and medium pitch custom gears, such as internal, spline, sprocket, helical, spur and worms/worm gears. Typical materials include 12L14, 1215, 4140, 8620, 9310 and various stainless grades, as well as aluminum, bronze, brass, Inconel, Hastelloy, titanium, plastics, wood fiber and powdered metal.
New Sunnen software made machine set-ups, operator training and overall operational efficiency more efficient for Forest City. The new software introduced features such as intuitive user interfaces, automated processes, easy tool set-ups and enhanced compatibility, allowing operators to set up machines more efficiently.
For more than 60 years, Forest City Gear has crafted a legacy of excellence in precision gear manufacturing, leveraging advanced techniques and cutting-edge technology to earn the business of customers as exclusive as NASA. At the heart of the company's technology-focused philosophy lies a longtime relationship with Sunnen Products Company, a manufacturer of honing systems, tooling and accessories. The relationship helped Forest City set itself apart as one of the world's most precise gear makers, and now the company's parts are found on everything from fishing reels to the Mars Rovers.
Stetler and Evelyn Young started Forest City Gear in 1955 after Stetler's employer, Rynel Gear, was sold and liquidated. When a former Rynel customer approached Stetler with a need for high-quality gears, Forest City Gear was born. Since then, the company leadership was assumed by Stetler and Evelyn's son, Fred Young, who ran the company for nearly 50 years, continuing its traditions of high-tech precision and innovation. Fred's daughter, Kika Young, is now company President.
"Staying on the forefront of machine tool technology goes to our core values because it makes us a better partner for our customers," said Kika. "Likewise, Sunnen checks all the boxes we are looking for in a partner: communication, quick response and quality equipment."
Forest City Gear does not produce standard, off-the-shelf gears; they specialize in crafting custom gear solutions tailored to the unique needs of diverse industries.
"Everything we make is custom, directly from a customer's design or CAD file," said Young. "Our company's strategic directive has always been `excellence without exception.' It boils down to always giving the customer a higher level of quality than specified, and to do it without adding much cost or time to a job. Our automated vertical honing systems allow us to hit tight tolerances and produce precision finishes, easily and efficiently, without adding production time."
About 30% of Forest City's work is aerospace-related, 5-10% medical, 5% military and the remainder is industrial or instrument work. Many of these applications require high process capability where honing provides critical advantages in control and consistency, according to the team at Forest City.
Evolution: From Parts to Assemblies
A company spokesperson said: "The collaboration with Sunnen has allowed Forest City Gear to ensure that each gear meets the highest standards of quality and reliability. It has also helped Forest City expand its product line to gear assemblies where precision also plays an important role."
"We evaluated our Sunnen hones and how we used them over the years, and as the gear tolerance requirements got tighter, we started to take over more of the value stream," said Jared Lyford, Director of Operations, Forest City Gear. "We used to be more of a cut-teeth production, then we migrated to whole-part-complete, from raw material to finished part. Even after ID grinding, we needed to have more finite control of the bore tolerances, and that is where the Sunnen machines came in. They allowed us to meet the roundness and perpendicularity for finished parts and in-process requirements for gear finishing."
Honing Makes the Difference
Forest City Gear's principal products are fine and medium pitch custom gears, such as internal, spline, sprocket, helical, spur and worms/worm gears. The company works to quality levels as high as AGMA 15 (DiN 2-3). Part runs range from one to several hundred thousand. Maximum OD on most parts is 20", except for worms (5") and worm gears (16"). Typical materials include 12L14, 1215, 4140, 8620, 9310 and various stainless grades, as well as aluminum, bronze, brass, Inconel, Hastelloy, titanium, plastics, wood fiber and powdered metal.
Honing, a precision machining process, plays a pivotal role in ensuring the superior quality and performance of Forest City Gear's products. By employing two Sunnen SV Series honing systems, as well as an SH-4000 tube hone, the shop achieves high accuracy and surface finish in its gears. This meticulous approach not only enhances the durability and reliability of the gears, but also optimizes their performance in various applications.
Forest City Gear has used honing since the inception of its business. The company also tried hard turning, but found it more difficult to control quality, especially for micro finishes.
"On bore-type gears, we have found that automated honing is a good way to give the customer tighter control of bore size, roundness, straightness and finish," said Joel Miller, ID/OD Department Supervisor at Forest City. Miller is responsible for the honing, lapping and grinding duties at Forest City. "The customer notices the difference in a smoother, quieter, more efficient drive."
"ID grinding is a fine process for gears with larger (>0.75") bores and low L/D ratios (0.5:1), but our range of work includes smaller diameters and relatively deep bores," Miller explained. "When you start to reach an L/D of 2:1, honing has a real advantage in speed of material removal, and over 5:1 you might start to see deflection on a grinding spindle, exacerbating taper issues."
Forest City uses Sunnen's diamond-plated CGT tooling with the Sunnen MB30 honing fluid.
"We have had excellent results with the diamond-plated tooling as far as consistency, cool cutting, holding size and long wear," added Miller. "The Sunnen machines are tanks. We depend on them to be accurate and repeatable. We can run on Friday afternoon hitting split limit, come back Monday morning, turn the machine on and we are within 20 millionths."
Software Upgrade Delivers Efficiency and Flexibility
Forest City Gear had been using honing systems for so long, that when it purchased its second SV Series machine in 2022, the software on the new machine had been upgraded. Fortunately, the new software is compatible with the older model honing machine, so a simple software upgrade was all that was needed.
"The entire software upgrade only took about two hours," said Miller. "We were back up and running the same day."
The new Sunnen software proved to be a game-changer for Forest City Gear by making machine set-ups, operator training and overall operational efficiency even more efficient. The new software introduced features such as intuitive user interfaces, automated processes, easy tool set-ups and enhanced compatibility.
"The intuitive nature of the new software reduced the learning curve for our operators," said Miller. "With the user-friendly interfaces and simplified workflows, operators can quickly grasp the functionalities of the software. This not only saved us resources in terms of training hours, but also enabled operators to become proficient more rapidly."
Through new software, Forest City gained access to advanced features designed to optimize various aspects of their operations. These include tools for process monitoring, data analysis and predictive maintenance, among others. These features allow the shop to identify and address inefficiencies more effectively, leading to smoother operations and improved overall performance.
"With this new software, our operators can monitor which fixture is running and where we are in the part run," added Miller. "This gives us built-in consistency across all operators and allows one operator to run multiple machines."
Fred Young's passion for innovation not only established Forest City as a go-to gear maker, but it also brought new best practices to the gear making industry as he willingly shared his methods and techniques. Fred passed away in 2023.
"All of us at Sunnen enjoyed working with Fred," said Tom Dustman, Sunnen's Director of Sales. "He was a true manufacturing icon, constantly pushing the boundaries of what could be done to improve the quality of gears, and then sharing whatever he learned with the entire industry rather than keeping it as a competitive advantage. The synergy that was created by Forest City Gear and Sunnen working together helped both companies improve our capabilities and quality."
For more information contact:
Forest City Gear
11715 Main Street
Roscoe, IL 61073
815-623-2168
quotes@forestcitygear.com
www.forestcitygear.com
Sunnen Products Company
7910 Manchester Road
St. Louis, MO 63143
800-325-3670 / 314-781-2100
sales@sunnen.com
www.sunnen.com